If you’re a fan of both the Harry Potter and Percy Jackson fantasy worlds, there’s a good chance that you’re considering who would win if they both were pitted against each other.
It’s a common scenario that people have when it comes to major characters, such as the infamous Captain Kirk versus Captain Picard.
It’s an even more popular scenario between different superhero universes, such as Batman versus Spider-Man.
Percy Jackson Vs. Harry Potter:
- Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson – A Magical Fight: Harry Potter would win a Magical fight
- Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson – A Physical Fight: Percy Jackson would win a Physical fight
- Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson – Real World Fight: Harry Potter would win Real World fight
It’s actually quite difficult to tell at first which one of these major fantasy characters in children’s literature would win in a battle against each other.
Both of them have gotten through challenging tasks and events, and both of them have heroic powers.
Even though Percy Jackson may seem to have an upper hand on the face of things, there are many possibilities when it comes to magical powers in the wizarding world.
Harry Potter’s Strengths and Weaknesses
An advantage this character has is obviously his magical abilities.
While he’s not the most academically minded wizard out there, he definitely has a lot of talent when it comes to casting spells and dealing with magical items.
He’s even one of the most proficient at the field of dark magic, though he only uses it when he has to.
Additionally, he’s also quite good at defending himself with protective spells and charms.
The main weakness that the famous wizard has is his lack of physical strength.
While he isn’t exactly weak in this area, it’s not one of his strong points.
While you may think that this is true of many witches and wizards, it’s not always the case.
For instance, Hagrid is a half-giant with enormous strength.
Also, Godric Gryffindor was known for his physical prowess during his time. If this is the movie version of Harry, this shortcoming is even more so.
Another weakness that this character has is that he doesn’t always think before he acts.
While this prevents him from taking up too much time in his decisions, it can be a hindrance to acting prudently.
Normally, a character could make up for this fact by having brute strength, such as that in a giant. However, that’s not the case here.
Percy Jackson’s Strengths and Weaknesses
Since this individual is part of the old mythological world and is a “demigod,” which is someone that’s half-human and half-mythological, it’s safe to say that he has a chance against most individuals.
In this case, he’s the son of Neptune and has command over water and the sea.
This makes him a literal powerful force of nature.
As a result, he’s most powerful when he’s in or around some kind of water.
That being said, one of his weaknesses is the fact that he’s not as powerful when around water.
Fortunately, water is so abundant, though that’s not always the case.
It seems that the amount of water is also important, making him more powerful at a lake than with only a water bottle.
If an opponent were able to get out of Percy Jackon’s area of control in time, the natural aquatic element would be completely useless.
Also, this character has a bit of a weakness when it comes to focusing on the task at hand. While it may not seem like a big disadvantage, it can be an incredible disadvantage when going against a talented and agile magic-user.
How would he deal with an opponent that creates optical illusions when he can’t focus on what’s right in front of him?
Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson
Now that you know where each character stands, it’s time to see who would come out victorious if they were pitted against each other.
This depends on variables around the event, such as where it takes place and what’s available.
The following will go over the main three circumstances.
Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson – A Magical Duel
In this circumstance, no physical contact is allowed by either participant.
Also, no creatures or monsters are allowed in this battle. It’s also a proper duel without any outside influence except for the surrounding spectators normally present at a one-on-one match.
Other than that, they’re allowed any objects that aren’t illegal in the real world, especially some of the darkest magical artifacts from either world.
The wizard will probably take up his wand, Cloak of Invisibility, flying broom, and any other magical objects he thinks is necessary.
Normally, this would allow him to sneak around the arena undetected, but his opponent could try to flood the whole area.
Regardless, the wizard has the agility to deal with anything big and nasty, such as a massive surge of water.
Also, who knows what other magical objects are available.
The mythological figure will probably bring a large body of water with him.
Otherwise, he would have no means to defend himself or attack his opponent, especially since physical contact isn’t allowed.
This brings a lot of creativity to what he has available, turning water into just about anything.
However, it’s likely there’s a magical way to render this all useless. It’s possible he could bring some legendary object, but so could his opponent.
Result: Harry Potter would probably win.
Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson – A Physical Duel
In this match, the opponents aren’t able to use any kind of magical object such as wands or such, rendering any spellcasting useless.
This includes any kind of water that the mythological hero could use against his opponent.
Does the incredible wizard, who’s still technically a human, have any chance against the powerful son of the ocean itself?
While you may think that it’s an obvious answer, it’s actually not so.
Consider what a wizard could do it prepare for the event.
Any kind of spellcasting knowledge would be useless during the match, but some magic that can be cast before the event occurs could last during the duel.
For instance, perhaps there’s a spell that could develop superhuman strength.
Another spell could develop superhuman agility.
There are many possibilities when it comes to the mystery of spellcasting.
What if prior spellcasting enchantments on oneself and any kind of clothing are banned entirely?
While the outcome doesn’t look great for the wizard, his chance of winning isn’t completely lost.
Consider the possibility of using some kind of time-bending spells to give him more time to prepare for the event.
Such magic was used by Hermoine Granger as a student at Hogwarts so it’s definitely possible.
This gives him the chance to develop his strength and consider some solution for winning.
Result: Percy Jackson would most probably win.
Harry Potter VS. Percy Jackson – In the Real World
This is where things get much more complicated.
In the real world, there aren’t any rules like those found in a duel. That brings many more possibilities for each of the characters to take advantage of.
However, neither of them would likely do anything considered evil or illegal, placing at least some rules in place.
Either one of them could win in a battle, making the aspects of the different variables in place the decision-maker.
Around a large body of water such as the ocean, Harry Potter would have a difficult time defending himself against Percy Jackson’s onslaught.
Such a substance can take on just about any shape or form, particularly when someone is controlling it with superhuman and mythological powers.
However, there are ways around this by using magic.
For instance, there must be a spell that allows the user to breathe underwater.
Also, wizards are quite powerful by themselves with just a wand that’s easy enough to carry around.
This allows them to bring their powers wherever they go.
They can also enchant regular objects to become something much more magical, such as a piece of clothing.
This brings a lot of versatility, making it incredibly difficult to determine what a witch or wizard is going to do in terms of action and reaction.
Magic is really only limited by imagination.
Additionally, there’s a strong element of randomness when it comes to the real world.
What if evil forces lurking in the world were spectating the battle and looking for ways to take advantage of the situation?
Both of these heroes would likely consider this aspect and try to prevent it before any kind of battle occurred between them.
This is why this kind of situation is so complicated, making it difficult in finalizing who would actually win.
Result: It depends on the circumstances, but maybe Harry Potter?
Conclusion
Thinking about whether Harry Potter or Percy Jackson would win if they dueled or battled each other can be a captivating thought experiment.
These are some of the most popular children’s books ever created, and trying to determine which characters in different fictional worlds are more powerful is an age-old question.
It’s been around since comic book superheroes were invented, and possibly even before then.
Of course, each heroic character was developed in different circumstances.
If Percy Jackson was a student at Hogwarts, would he learn the art of magic?
Possibly, though it’s not very likely. Spellcraft is a superpower in itself, giving Harry Potter more than a fighting chance against even some of the greatest individuals.
While most people find this kind of thing fun to think about, there isn’t a clear answer that’s easy to determine.